Journal
ProcessJune 23, 20268 min read

What to Expect When You Hire a Designer

Most disappointing design projects aren't ruined by bad taste. They're ruined by mismatched expectations nobody named out loud.

If you've never hired a designer before, the process can feel opaque — you hand over money and a vague hope, and somewhere in a black box a finished thing is supposed to appear. When it goes wrong, it's rarely because the designer lacked talent. It's because nobody named the expectations out loud: what the work includes, how long it takes, what's needed from the client, and what "done" actually looks like. So here is an honest account of what to expect, written for the person doing this for the first time.

We'd rather over-explain this up front than have a great project sour over a misunderstanding that a five-minute conversation could have prevented. A good working relationship is built on knowing what's coming.

It starts with questions, not sketches

The first surprise for many first-time clients is that we don't open a sketchbook on day one. We ask questions — sometimes more than feels comfortable. Who is this for? What does success look like a year from now? What has to stay, and what would you happily burn down? This isn't us stalling; it's the most important part of the job. A designer who starts drawing before understanding the problem is just decorating a guess. The brief behind the brief — the real problem underneath "we need a new look" — is what we're digging for, and the quality of the final work is set here, before anything visual exists.

So expect to talk, and expect to be asked things you may not have a ready answer for. Those are usually the questions worth sitting with. The more honestly you can answer them, the better the work that follows.

Good design takes time, and the time is the point

Design is not instant, and the parts that take longest are the parts that don't look like work. Thinking, researching the landscape, exploring directions that get rejected on purpose, refining a detail until it stops looking arbitrary — this is where quality comes from, and none of it photographs well. A first-time client sometimes sees a logo and thinks, that's just two shapes, why did it take weeks? The answer is that the two shapes are the survivors of a hundred that didn't work, and the simplicity that looks effortless is the most time-consuming thing to achieve.

If a final design looks obvious — like it could only ever have been this — that's not a sign it was easy. That's usually a sign of how much work went into making it look inevitable.

Rushing is where quality dies. When a timeline gets compressed, the thinking and the refining are what get cut, because they're invisible, and the work comes out shallower for it. A realistic schedule isn't padding; it's the room the quality needs to happen in.

You are part of the work

The best outcomes come from clients who stay involved, and the worst from clients who vanish after the brief and reappear at the end with opinions. We'll come back to you at deliberate points — to confirm the brief, to choose between directions, to refine in focused rounds — and what we need at each is engaged, specific feedback, given reasonably promptly. "This one feels more like us" is gold; "I'll know it when I see it" leaves everyone guessing. Feedback is most useful when it describes the problem you're sensing rather than prescribing the fix, which is our job to find.

Expect, too, that we'll sometimes push back. If an instinct is leading the work somewhere weaker, the honest thing — and what you're actually paying for — is to say so and explain why. A designer who only ever agrees is just an expensive pair of hands. The collaboration, the back-and-forth between your knowledge of the business and ours of the craft, is where the real value lives.

What "done" looks like

Finally, know what you're actually getting at the end, because "done" should mean usable, not just finished. For an identity, that means logo files in every format you'll need — vector and raster, full-colour, single-colour, and reversed — the colour values in HEX, CMYK, and Pantone, the fonts and their licences, and a practical guide for whoever has to use it all after us. The deliverable is something you can hand to a printer or a new hire and have it still hold together, not a single pretty file that lives on the designer's machine.

Hire a designer expecting all of this — a process that starts with questions, takes real time, needs you in it, and ends with assets you can genuinely use — and you're far more likely to get work you're glad you paid for. Most of the disappointment in this field comes from expectations nobody set. Set them, and the rest gets a great deal easier.

Working on something we could help with?

Start a project